Every agency leader knows this moment. You’ve built a recommendation you believe in and prepared to present it. Then the person across the table hesitates, fixes on a minor detail, or asks a question that shows their mind is somewhere else entirely.
When that happens, our first instinct is to explain the idea better. I saw this play out clearly with a director I once worked with.
She had pinpointed why scopes of work kept causing friction at her agency.
Projects were expanding without discussion and the team was absorbing hours that never made it onto an invoice. So she designed a thoughtful process to fix it and scheduled time to present it to the founder.
A few minutes in, the founder interrupted to ask whether the new process would slow down sales.
She had been talking about how the work would be managed, while he was thinking about growth. So she went back through the process in more detail, and with each step, she lost a little more of his attention.
When we talked afterward, I asked her what the founder had been most concerned about before the meeting. She answered right away: “Growth. It’s always growth.”
She’d known all along. She simply hadn’t started there.
Why this keeps happening
What happened to her is incredibly common.
Most of us present ideas the way we’d prefer to receive them, and when an idea isn’t landing, our instinct is to push harder in the same direction, with more detail or more conviction.
The gap is never about effort so more of the same rarely helps.
Four ways people take in an idea
Over years of working with agency leaders, I’ve noticed four broad patterns in how people take in a new idea. Most people lean on more than one, and their preference can shift when the stakes rise.
Results. They want the recommendation and the outcome first. Too much background, and they disengage.
Possibility. They connect with where an idea could lead. Starting with process can lose them early.
Evidence. They want to understand how you reached your conclusion. When an idea feels rushed, they hesitate.
People. They think about the team, the customers and how change will be introduced. They need to know everyone will be supported.
The recommendation can stay exactly the same but what changes is your entry point.
Why this matters for agency owners
In many agencies, the owner is the one person who can consistently get an idea approved.
The cost is that they need to be part of every important conversation: every proposal, every difficult recommendation, every discussion about scope.
That’s one of the most common reasons I see agencies plateau.
When your team learns how to get their ideas to land, you no longer have to carry every conversation. That’s what makes this a leadership skill and a scaling skill.
Listen to the full episode
On this week’s episode of the Small But Mighty Agency podcast, I share the one I naturally default to, how to read the room when an idea isn’t landing, and how to prepare so your idea connects with whoever is across the table.
I also walk through how that director could have opened the conversation differently.
Which of the four do you naturally lean on? Share it in the comments.
